Club Sea Ray

  • Search forums

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.

  • Sea Ray Boats
  • Sport Yachts/Yachts

420 SD vs Tiara 4300 Sovran - help me decide.

  • Thread starter sb in gp
  • Start date Nov 3, 2013
  • Nov 3, 2013

sb in gp

Active Member

It's been a while since I posted here. I'd appreciate advice/opinions from the great CSR crowd. I'm looking to upgrade from my 320 to something a little bigger. Here are my primary needs: Would like to have more cabin room for longer range cruising in the Great Lakes (3-10 days overnight). The 320 is a great boat but with 4 sleeping aboard my wife has stumbled to the head in the dark for the last time. Kids are teenagers now, so if we're going to travel, we'll likely be taking friends. Would also like to travel with another couple down the road, so separate quarters is a must. I've narrowed my search down to two boats: 2005 420 SD with about 700 hours (Cummins 480) 2006 Tiara 4300 Sovran with about 300 hours (Volvo IPS 500) Both are loaded, and in great shape. Space / Sleeping quarters: The 420 has quite a bit more room, due to the bridge. I think the 420 can sleep 6 comfortably, and the Tiara sleeps 4 comfortably. Price: The Tiara is about $50K more - I could afford it, but not sure I want to go that far into debt. Resale value: I see the Tiara having better resale value, plus it is a year newer Maintenance: Weekly maintenance is less on the Tiara without all the isinglass and canvas. Maintaining the IPS pods will add costs, not sure how much. Performance: I think the Tiara is a better handling boat by far, the bridge boat is going to be tippy, and the IPS system is hard to match. Is the tipping feel a big issue coming from a Sundancer? The 420 has bow and stern thrusters so dock maneuvering should not be an issue. Does anyone think the Tiara is going to be underpowered with the 500's? Sorry to be so long winded. Any advice would be appreciated.  

ZZ13

Well-Known Member

I am going through the exact same process. Here are my thoughts on our situation and maybe you can get something out of it. I had a 300 Sundancer that we ended up mostly using for day boating (hanging out on the hook all day - but returning to the slip and going home at the end of the day). My wife ended up not liking the underground cave feeling and she preferred not to sleep on it because of that. She wants the open condo/apartment feeling of a bridge boat. So it ended up being my man-cave and a big toilet area for her for our day outings. We just moved to coastal South Carolina and our boating style will switch to destination boating to stay on the boat for up to a week (maybe two weeks) at friend's locations in cities between 30 and 200 miles away. I love Tiara's and would own one over a comparable Sea Ray all things being equal, but price was out of the question for me and its still an underground finished basement. So the spouse would have nixed it. So we are working on finding a 400DB (the 420DB is out of my price range). So for us, the style of the boat was most important along with price, obviously. Make sure you are OK with the underground living if you go with the Tiara. Hope that helps.  

JV II

sb in gp said: Here are my primary needs: Would like to have more cabin room for longer range cruising in the Great Lakes (3-10 days overnight). Would also like to travel with another couple down the road, so separate quarters is a must. 2005 420 SD with about 700 hours (Cummins 480) 2006 Tiara 4300 Sovran with about 300 hours (Volvo IPS 500) Click to expand...

fwebster

The 420DB isn't a "tippy" boat by any stretch of the imagination. They are solid and well proportioned and are infact, one of the more predictable small bridge boats around. The feeling you get is quite common for a DA owner moving up to a DB....takes about a day to get over it. However, the ride is completely different on a DB. Since you are about 8 ft higher than on a comparable DA, you get some added moment to any wave action. A strong beam sea tends to amplify the motion, but I still find it manageable. My background is pretty diverse.....I run boats for the local dealer and run a 54 Hat and a 55 Viking for friends so I spend quite a bit of time on bridge boats. A boat is a boat to me. I own a DA and prefer them for ease of maintenance and operation but the ride really doesn't matter to me.  

The 2006 version of IPS is prone to a few known issues. Volvo has updated the material used on the seals and the old drives are prone to water intrusion, make sure the drives have been updated. The 43 Sovran is a great boat, however its not as seaworthy as the open series due to the wide beam (14'"9). This is our 2nd boat with IPS and we would never go back to conventional drives.  

  • Nov 4, 2013

I would second all of the positive notes on the 420DB. We recently purchased a 420DB for all of the reasons given. We have been on board a 400DB a number of times and we really liked the design and space of the sedan bridge. Our 2005 420 has the step up dining table which has a better view than the 400. Also having two heads with showers is really nice. Moving up from sail boats I was concerned about movement, but the 420 seems stable and the hull design is one of the best in this size class as stated by seasoned power boaters.  

Thanks for all the feedback. Very helpful.  

  • Nov 6, 2013

timemachine

timemachine

I had a similar dilemma between 43 sovran and 420 Sundancer. Decided on sundancer because of engines and drives. I really like having shafts over pods and the 65K savings was nice too  

kevin27

What about something like this beast? http://www.boattrader.com/listing/1998-Tiara-43-CV-101805050 or this http://www.boattrader.com/listing/2006-Tiara-convertible-99069712 These boats will have very good range and are tanks.  

  • Nov 9, 2013

Thanks Kevin. Both look like great boats. It does not look like the first boat has 2 cabins, and the second has no swim platform. I think shipping either of these from FL to MI is going to be costly because they'll have to take the bridge off. I also prefer how the 420 DB has seating area on the bridge so that you can drive with your guests nearby. Scott  

  • Nov 10, 2013

Carver370

There are a few 43 Convertible Tiaras in the Great Lakes, one actually that is completely updated and beautiful. Take another look  

  • Dec 27, 2013

Ok, let me ask the question again with a twist: I have found a 2006 Tiara 4300 Sovran and a 2005 Sea Ray 420 Sedan Bridge and negotiated to the same price. The Tiara is in salt, and the Sea Ray is all freshwater. Thoughts? Thanks, Scott  

HUMPH

The 420DB is one pretty boat! Fresh water wins as well.  

Alex F

sb in gp said: Ok, let me ask the question again with a twist: I have found a 2006 Tiara 4300 Sovran and a 2005 Sea Ray 420 Sedan Bridge and negotiated to the same price. The Tiara is in salt, and the Sea Ray is all freshwater. Thoughts? Thanks, Scott Click to expand...

sbw1

If the 4300 Sovran is in the mix a 42 Open should be considered as well. Straight inboards,lots of room, choice of layouts, and great sea keeping qualities would make it worthy of a look.  

Art

  • Dec 28, 2013

Thanks everyone. Good stuff. A couple of comments: I've looked at a 42 Open, and it seems you give up a lot of interior space to accommodate the huge deck. It is a fantastic boat, built like a tank, but we want to sleep another couple and sometimes 6 people or more aboard. I don't see the 42 Open working for that. I view the Tiara 4300 as having just enough room for us, with little extra. The 420DB has at least 20% more space, and I love the "living room" feel of the salon being above the water and having great light. I dislike the basement feel of normal cruisers when you're below deck. I view the Tiara as a better boat overall, as far a fit/finish and quality of components. I think the Tiara will have better resale value and will be more desirable to the next buyer when I'm through with it. Resale value is offset by the salt. I think the Tiara will handle rough water a little better. At the end of the day, both boats would work as far as space, looks, handling and performance. Both are in great shape. The biggest things on my mind right now are: Resale value Salt Shipping hassles (FL to MI) - cost ($10K+), and having to remove pods and arch components to ship Ongoing costs of maintaining IPS system (I've heard $1500 - $2000 per year) Better handling with IPS (Would be nice to have a boat my wife could dock with the joystick - 420 DB has bow and stern thrusters though) Less plastic/canvas to maintain on the Tiara (Tiara has hardtop with glass windshield) So I've literally flipped back and forth on a daily basis. If I'm missing anything, please chime in. Thanks for being my therapists and listening to my ramblings. I'll let you know how it turns out. Decision needs to be made in next 10 days or so. Scott  

Have you actually been on the 43 you are negotiating on? If not that could really throw a wrench in the mix. There's items on salt boats that if even just cosmetic I couldn't live with unless there was someone like me who me who owned it. Corrosion and rust on things would drive me absolutely crazy.  

Short Drive?  

The 42 Open comes with a plan C that adds a guest stateroom with two big bunk beds in it.....very comfortable for two adults and makes 6 overnight reasonably comfortable. Was popular with families with teenage children. When you own an Open series Tiara you spend lots of time on the bridge deck. Many of these boats have helm a/c that keep the helms at 68-72 degrees in hot weather. We live upstairs and go below to get out of the bright sunlight. You will know what works for your situation. I've driven the Sovran series and own an Open. Both are excellent sea boats with nod going to the Opens. Agree with the comment on IPS system maintenance costs. Don't feel the trade off off of docking ease and mpg is worth giving up the straight drives' simplicity.  

tiara yachts vs sea ray

Forum statistics

  • THE PRINCESS PASSPORT
  • Email Newsletter
  • Yacht Walkthroughs
  • Destinations
  • Electronics
  • Boating Safety
  • Ultimate Boat Giveaway

Yachting Magazine logo

10 Yachts You Can Have Now

  • By Yachting Staff
  • Updated: May 30, 2018

tiara yachts vs sea ray

It’s never too early to think about that next yacht. And Yachting wants to help in your search for that dream boat. Our staff travels the world to find our on-the-water enthusiasts new vessels, ranging from tenders and day boats to midsize cruising craft, larger motoryachts and mega-yachts. We take them out on the salt and see how they do.

Without further ado, here are 10 yachts that we’ve taken to sea from Brisbane to Biscayne Bay, to see how they performed on the brine. Whether you’re looking for a multipurpose day boat, an express cruiser, a stylish pedigree import or even something that pushes the boatbuilding technology envelope, you’ll find it here.

Riva 56 Rivale

Riva 56 Rivale

Rivas are yachts of a different breed and, as they say, vive la différence. The 56 Rivale does not beat her competition by being faster, offering more accommodations, or even by being better engineered — although she happens to score very highly in that last category. Instead, she wins by presenting just about every square inch of her many attributes in the most exquisite of bundles. Few brands have such caché. — Phil Draper , “ The Riva 56 Rivale is Undisputed “

Okean Yachts, Okean 50 Flybridge Motor Yacht, HMY Yacht Sales

Okean 50 Flybridge Motor Yacht

The boat doesn’t just make an impression with her looks. Her layout, particularly on the main deck, was a hit when she debuted stateside at the 2017 Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show, and it’s plain to see why. Those windows allow as close to fully unobstructed salon views as I can recall seeing aboard a yacht, plus two hydraulic, foldout bulwarks lower to port and starboard. This act of oceangoing origami increases the Okean’s beam from 14 feet 7 inches to 20 feet 7 inches, making her an excellent party platform. — Kevin Koenig , “ Okean 50 is a Brazilian Beauty “

adler suprema

Adler Suprema

The near omnipresent Italian design firm Nuvolari-Lenard penned the Suprema’s plumb bow, crisp sheer line and aggressively raked superstructure, as well as her interior. This firm has drawn an array of well-known production, semicustom and custom craft. Each yacht has its own signature, but, overall, Nuvolari-Lenard creates an upscale ambience that translates into all of its designs. — Patrick Sciacca , “ A New Tack: The Adler Suprema “

Princess Yachts S60

Princess Yachts S60

The galley is aft and to port, a design choice that is becoming standard among Princess builds. The aft galley lends itself well to more casual boating, since the galley acts as a bridge between the salon and the cockpit. Its aft counter has a top-hinged window that opens to let the space double as an alfresco bar in the cockpit, to further meld the interior and exterior. This feature complements the cockpit’s U-shaped dining settee to make it a more complete entertaining area.

And complete is the key word. There’s little that this yacht can’t do. She’s fast, cruisable and fun with loads of stowage and entertainment space, and cool design details inside and out make her stand out in a crowded field. — Kevin Koenig , “ Inside the Stylish, Sporty Princess Yachts S60 “

Boston Whaler 350 Realm

Boston Whaler 350 Realm

I loved the 13-foot and 16-foot Boston Whalers I had a half-century ago, so I was eager to run Boston Whaler’s new 350 Realm. It melds the workmanlike qualities of a center console with the luxuries expected on today’s cabin craft. For sure, the 350 Realm is more than a one-activity center console for the family. It’s also set up for entertaining, fishing, overnight cruising and diving. — Chris Caswell , “ Boston Whaler 350 Realm is the SUV of the Sea “

Tiara Sport 38LS

Tiara Sport 38LS

The 38 LS fuses center console sensibilities with the amenities of an express day cruiser. Tiara’s design team created distinct social zones, with wraparound seating forward and a clever turntable dinette aft.

In between is the enclosable helm area with triple bucket seats, and a teak-trimmed console with room for dual 16-inch Garmin monitors. There are Yamaha Helm Master shifter/throttle controls as well as a joystick for easy maneuvering, and a standard bow thruster. — Chris Caswell , “ Tiara Launches its Sport Line “

Sea Ray Fly 520

Sea Ray Fly 520

I’ve been reviewing Sea Rays since company founder Connie Ray was still driving the train, and I’ve often used adjectives like well-built and ­family-friendly to describe new models. But when I stepped aboard the Sea Ray Fly 520, a different word came to mind: elegant. — Chris Caswell , “ Meet the Sea Ray Fly 520 “

MJM 43z

I ran that owner’s 43z, Annabelle III, from his home port. The yacht has an elegant, long forefoot, tall pilothouse and soft tumblehome, with the white Verados on the stern. He chose a custom gray exterior with an orange stripe (he modeled it after the Porsche 911 GT3 RS) that makes for a stylish contrast to the white topsides. Simply tacking the outboards to the stern could have ruined the classic MJM profile, but [naval architect Doug] Zurn sculpted the transom so the new engines were integral to the design. The yacht also has two side doors and transom doors for access from the dock, and standard features that include helm electronics, Lectrotab electric trim tabs, a Fusion entertainment system, a VacuFlush head, an Indel Webasto freezer and a memory-foam mattress. — Michael Verdon , “ MJM’s 43z Adds Outboards to Traditional Design “

Horizon PC74

Horizon PC74

The  first  thing  to catch my gaze on the PC74 from Horizon Power Catamarans was the high freeboard forward. It sloped aft, gently, via an unbroken sheer line that was curved like a wave. It was the kind of styling that I’m used to seeing on monohull power yachts, not on twin-hull designs.

As it turns out, my response was exactly what Stuart Hegerstrom had hoped to achieve. As founder and director of The Powercat Company, a Horizon Power Catamarans distributor, he had long believed that catamaran builders needed to design their yachts to more stylish standards. — Tom Serio , “ Horizon Power Catamaran’s PC74 Offers a Lot “

Riviera 525 SUV

Riviera 525 SUV

Yachting took the Riviera 525 SUV out for a spin in the Tasman Sea in Sydney, just before the opening of the Sydney International Boat Show. We cruised by world-famous Bondi Beach and other beautiful parts of Sydney’s coast.

The 525 SUV fills the gap in a model series that includes a 445 and a 575. Our test vessel was powered by twin 725 hp Volvo Penta IPS950 diesels, providing an easy 24-knot cruise speed. — “ Sea Trial: Yachting Tests the Riviera 525 SUV “

  • More: Adler Yachts , Boston Whaler , HMY Yachts , Horizon Yachts , MJM yachts , Princess Yachts , Riva , Riviera Yachts , Sea Ray , Tiara , Yachts
  • More Yachts

outboard motors at sunset

Offshore Fishing Boats and Insurance Prices

Princess Yachts Y95

Discover the Princess Yachts Y95

Aquila 47 Molokai

Aquila 47 Molokai Reviewed

Ferretti Infynito 80

Ferretti Launches the First Infynito 80

Ferretti Yachts 850

For Sale: 2021 Ferretti Yachts 850

Aquila 47 Molokai

KVH Expands Starlink Maritime Options

Ocean Alexander 78 Enclosed Bridge

For Sale: Ocean Alexander 78 Enclosed Bridge

Yachting Magazine logo

  • Digital Edition
  • Customer Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Email Newsletters
  • Cruising World
  • Sailing World
  • Salt Water Sportsman
  • Sport Fishing
  • Wakeboarding

Iboats

  • CREATE AN ACCOUNT
  • Boat Cover Finder
  • Bimini Top Finder
  • Boat Propeller Finder
  • Engine Parts Finder
  • Anchor & Dock
  • Watersports
  • Clothing and Footwear
  • Engine Parts
  • Cabin and Galley
  • Covers and Biminis
  • Electronics
  • Paint and Maintenance
  • Pumps and Plumbing
  • Anchor Chains & Ropes
  • Boat Fenders
  • Boat Mooring
  • Boat Protection
  • Dock Storage & Protection
  • Ladders, Steps, & Platforms
  • Top Sellers

Iboats

  • Fishing Rods
  • Fishing Reels
  • Fishing Rod & Reel Combos
  • Fishing Tools & Tackle Boxes
  • Fishing Line
  • Fly Fishing
  • Fishing Bait & Fishing Lures
  • Fishing Rod Holders & Storage Racks
  • Fish Finders, Sounders & Sonar
  • Trolling Motors
  • Fishing Nets
  • Fishing Downriggers & Acessories
  • Fishing Outriggers & Acessories
  • Fishing Kayaks
  • Fish Cleaning Tables

Iboats

  • Inflatable Rafts
  • Paddle Boarding
  • Paddles & Oars
  • Wakeboard, Wakesurf & Ski
  • Wakeboard Towers
  • Tow Ropes & Handles
  • Life Jackets & PFDs
  • Snow Sports
  • Roof Racks, Carriers, Dollies

Iboats

Men's Clothing

  • Accessories

Men's Footwear

  • Atheltic Shoes
  • Water Shoes

Women's Clothing

  • Dresses & Skirts

Women's Footwear

  • Fuel Systems
  • Sacrificial Anodes & Zincs
  • Generator Parts
  • Inflatable Boats
  • Propeller Parts & Accessories
  • Boat Manuals
  • PWC Parts & Accessories

Iboats

  • Fishing Boat Seats
  • Offshore Boat Seats
  • Ski Boat Seats
  • Pontoon Boat Seats & Furniture
  • Boat Seat Pedestals & Hardware
  • Boat Seats by Manufacturer
  • Boat Tables & Hardware
  • Boat Seat Covers
  • Boat Seat Vinyl
  • Floating Boat Cushions

Iboats

  • Barbeque Grills
  • Boat Drink Holders
  • Cabin Accessories & Hardware
  • Boat Ventilation
  • Interior & Cabin Lighting
  • Marine Teak Products
  • Carbon Monoxide & Smoke Detectors
  • Binoculars & Telescopes

Iboats

Boat Bimini Tops

  • Bimini Top Accessories
  • Pontoon Bimini Tops
  • Other Biminis
  • RV & Trailer Covers
  • Boat Shrink Wrap & Accessories
  • Boat Shelters

Boat Covers

  • Boat Cover Accessories
  • Boat Lift Canopy Covers
  • Other Covers
  • Boat Wiring & Cable
  • Marine Batteries & Accessories
  • Marine DC Power Plugs & Sockets
  • Marine Electrical Meters
  • Boat Lights
  • Marine Electrical Panels & Circuit Breakers
  • Power Packs & Jump Starters
  • Marine Solar Power Accessories
  • Marine Electrical Terminals
  • Marine Fuse Blocks & Terminal Blocks
  • Marine Switches
  • Shore Power & AC Distribution

Iboats

  • Marine Audio & Video
  • GPS Chartplotters & Accessories
  • Electronic Navigation Charts & Software
  • Digital Instruments
  • Display Mounts
  • VHF Radios & Communication
  • Marine Radar
  • Auto Pilot Systems
  • Action Cameras

Iboats

  • Fiberglass & Epoxy Boat Repair
  • Boat Paint & Varnish
  • Marine Adhesives, Sealant, & Caulking
  • Marine Engine Maintenance
  • Boat Cleaners & Waxes
  • Boat Cleaning Supplies

Iboats

  • Fresh Water Boat Systems
  • Bilge Pumps
  • Marine Plumbing Parts
  • Wash Down Pumps
  • Livewell Aerator Pumps & Live Bait Wells
  • Toilet & Waste Pumps
  • Marine Pump Replacement Parts

Iboats

  • Tires, Rims, & Hub Kits
  • Boat Trailer Winches
  • Boat Motor Supports & Transom Savers
  • Boat Trailer Guides & Rollers
  • Boat Trailer Fenders
  • Boat Trailer Lights
  • Boat Trailer Hardware
  • Boat Trailer Jacks
  • Boat Trailer Brakes & Axles
  • Boat Trailer Tie Downs
  • Couplers, Mounts, Hitches, & Locks

Iboats

  • Boat Deck Harware
  • Marine Nuts, Bolts, & Screws
  • Boat Handles, Pulls, & Rings
  • Prop Nut Kits & Hardware
  • Boat Cabin Hardware
  • Marine Fasteners
  • Boat Windshield Parts
  • Boat Tubing & Rails
  • Boat Mirrors
  • Marine Tools & Tool Kits
  • Boat Lettering

Iboats

  • Women's Clothing Deals
  • Men's Clothing Deals
  • Fishing Deals
  • Anchor & Dock Deals
  • Electrical Deals
  • Electronics Deals
  • Paint & Maintenance Deals
  • Pumps & Plumbing Deals
  • Boat Seats Deals
  • Trailering Deals
  • Camping & RV Deals
  • Dealer Login

Iboats

  • Forums Login

Iboats

  • Search forums
  • General Boating/Outdoors Activities
  • Boat Topics and Questions (not engine topics)

Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal?

  • Thread starter csanna2
  • Start date May 26, 2006
  • May 26, 2006

I just thought I weould ask I always thought searays where the best but everyone at work says regals make a better boat!  

tommays

Petty Officer 2nd Class

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? searay has a better reputation, but thats also the same company that builds bayliner  

"Retired" Association of Marine Technicians...

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? Cobalt and Tiara are the only ones I have felt comfortable letting a customer see when they first come off of the factory trailer.  

Rock Hall

Petty Officer 1st Class

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? I own a Searay. Love it. But I'm looking at some Regals and wouldnt hesitate to buy one.  

  • May 27, 2006

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? Here is my personal rank when it comes to quality<br /><br />1. Cobalt<br />2. Sea Ray<br />3. Chris Craft <br />4. Regal<br />5. Chapparal<br />6. Rinker<br />7. Mariah<br />8. Wellcraft<br />9. Baja<br />10. Glastron<br />....<br />100. Bayliner!!  

Kevin70

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? Hey.....I resent that  

Bondo

Originally posted by hudman:<br /> searay has a better reputation, but thats also the same company that builds bilgeliner Click to expand...

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? look at what hudman said above...I'm not alone here  

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? None of the above mentioned scows is an inboard or I/O Engine.<br /><br />Moving to Boats.  

Lieutenant Commander

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? Dunno about the big cruisers. But Sea Ray deckboats and Select bowriders are more plush than Regal. Some insiders say the Regals have better construction. Sea Ray may have an edge in customer service, of course that is mostly up to your local dealer. Regal deckboats and bowriders are typically priced well under Sea Ray. More at the Four Winns price level. Which I would attribute to the difference in the plush factor. And the smaller market position.<br /><br />Kelly Cook  

bigbad 4cyl x2

bigbad 4cyl x2

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? searay sundeck is the best boat on the planet.  

studlymandingo

studlymandingo

  • May 28, 2006

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? Any boat is only as good as the care that has been given to it by the previous owners. Even a Sea Ray that has been neglected for 10 years will be worse than a Bayliner that has been meticiously cared for and garage-kept.<br /><br />Tommays- where was that photo taken?? Venice?  

  • May 29, 2006

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? Depends on what length your looking at ........After 16 years with SeaRays I went Regal ...... Fastrac hull had alot to do with it , but I just found the quality in the smaller versions way better in the Regal .price was not the issue FWIW  

Senior Chief Petty Officer

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? They are both stamped out mediocre quality production boats. Which is better is probably more a matter of whether yours was built on Monday/Friday or not.  

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? What you can see is pretty close to perfect looking on both boats<br /><br />What you cant get to with ripping apart thm apart is were the difference is and who can really say unless they were there for the build of that hull<br /><br />Haveing been luckey enough to own one hand built low production boat(J-24 sailboat )<br /><br />I can say that my power boat is Ok BUT NONE of these boats are even remotly as well built as a low production hull<br /><br />(there is no place to hide shortcuts in a J-24 hull)<br /><br /><br />tommays  

Texasmark

Supreme Mariner

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? So I read all the threads. I also have a working knowledge of Sea Ray. If I were interested in that size boat would own one in a heartbeat. They don't have to take a backseat to anyone......bar none.<br /><br />Mark  

Manipulator

  • May 30, 2006

Re: Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal? J.D. Power Ratings - Small Runabouts (16-19 ft.) <br />Boat Builder Overall Rating Quality & Reliability Value for Money Exterior Ride & Handling Features <br />Crownline <br />Chaparral <br />Four Winns <br />Sea Ray <br />Glastron <br />Bayliner  

blouderback

blouderback

yachtsurvey.com

  • All Articles
  • Order Books
  • Boat Reviews
  • Buying a Boat
  • Cores & Structural Issues
  • Marine Engines
  • Maintenance & Repairs
  • Hull Blisters
  • Marine Surveying
  • Insurance Issues
  • Fuel Issues
  • Boat Handling & Boat Safety
  • Hurricane Preparations

Tiara Today

Tiara: the new quality leader, by david pascoe.

We've always liked Tiara and Pursuit boats, both products of S2 Yachts of Holland, Michigan. In times past we've recommended them as good, solid quality, well-designed boats that are a bit more utilitarian than glitzy. The kind of boat that holds up well to year 'round use under the blazing Florida sun, as well as the five month monsoon season that can dump 80" of rain on your boat annually.

One of the things I've always liked about them was how they restrained themselves from loading their boats up with cheap hardware and other gratuitous junk just to give you the appearance of getting more. No plastic hardware to turn black with mildew, or to disintegrate from sunlight. No die cast zinc alloy or crummy aluminum.

Naturally, as surveyors, our primary business is with used boats, so we are usually several years behind the times on new models. Thus, it was several years ago that we began to notice a change in Tiara. For one thing, they started making an appeal to the high end sport fishing market. Whereas boats like the 3600 Open had rather plane-Jane cockpits, now we started seeing things like built in bait wells, tackle centers, rod storage lockers, Rybovich style hull vents and all those kind of goodies. Keeping up with the sport fishing Joneses as it were.

But the sport fishing market is a rather limited one, and so Tiara has wisely taken their "open" line of models and created both dedicated fishermen and cruisers. The primary difference of the two being the amount of seating and lack of obstructions in the cockpit areas for the fishermen.

Most recently we were assigned the task of looking over three brand new Tiaras. Now we get to see up close and personal what we'd previously been seeing only from a distance. Without question, Tiara has raised the quality a notch or two. Which, of course, means that the price tag has gone up along with it. That should go without saying. Want good? Gotta pay for it. We can say without reservation that, for the price, what you are getting is not a snow job, not some marketing ploy to sell you something that looks good today, but turns to dust tomorrow. No, these boats have some bone deep quality in them.

First off, we got to compare the 35 Open with the 4100. As is common in the industry, the overall quality tends to go up with the size and price of the boat, and that is clearly the case here. With the 4300 Open, Tiara is clearly taking a shot at Viking and Hatteras, with all the latest design, quality and style features to match. As for Hatteras, they seem too busy with their mega yacht business to bother with the little guys. Can't remember when we last looked at a late model under 50 feet.

The interior of the 4300 is a real eye-catcher. Done out all in teak (Gasp! Dark wood!) it is positively scrumptious. I wish a picture could tell the story, but it really can't. The last time we raved about quality wood work was on the 1997 Viking 43 SF which had less of it, but better overall quality. Frankly, I'm glad to see teak interiors making a come back. Why? For one thing, it is durable. If you screw it all up, the finish can be restored. Not so with light color woods like ash, oak and maple that get permanently stained.

Tiara 4300 Open

The 4300 Open. No pretense at luxury here, it looks better live than this photo.

Up north, where the sun doesn't shine that much, dark interiors are understandably unpopular. But here in the tropics, sunny days can get just as boring -- not to mention the blinding light, heat and carcinoma that it causes -- so popping down into your deep dark abode immediately renders a sense of soothing coolness, away from the glare and shutting out the rest of the world. If you like that sort of atmosphere, you'll love this one. And it is decidedly masculine. No red or green leather and brass, but you can get teal. Close enough. Spittoons and cigar clippers are optional, for those of you who defy convention and love your Monte Chistos and La Habanas. Easy clean vinyl headliner if you're into the soothing effects of tobacco.

With the 4300, start with a beveled edge, tongue-and-groove teak planked sole with holly stepping. Not the most practical design in terms of keeping dirt out of the cracks, but boy it sure looks great. The sculptured effect is immediately obvious and exudes an amazing sense of quality. Then we've got a fold up dinette table with round, solid teak edge banding a good 2" thick with 180 degree round over; joiner work is first class.

The 3500 had a limed ash or oak interior that was nice, but the veneers weren't the best, nor was the joiner work really great. There were cabinets and drawers veneer faced with veneer edge banding that left very hard corners and a failure to give the impression of great workmanship. Nice, but not impressive to those who recognize quality; the finish on the wood was also thin. Contrasting this with the 4300, where we find a lot more rounding, the finish is obviously well done. So what's the big deal with rounding? Well, for one thing square is cheaper to make than round. Secondly, I'd much rather bump into a rounded corner than a sharp one. I got enough scars on my body. But the finish on the woods is clearly better than the 3500, giving the impression (whether it is or not) of overall higher quality and better workmanship.

The overall design, selection of materials and color scheme is superb. Everything is mute without appearing dull. Color freaks won't care for this, but when it comes to a yacht, it's foolish to stray into the realm of the trendy or flashy. Gotta think about resale; if it's loud, it gets hard to sell when the flavor of the day constantly changes. The color schemes used here are timeless and will not go out of style. Call it subdued good taste. Smart money stays conservative. Moreover, the use of foam padded vinyl is kept to a merciful minimum and you're new Tiara won't smell like like a vinyl factory; instead, it smells like wood.

Full, fiberglass liners make our day for the head compartments, with hose-down ease of cleaning on the smaller models, stall showers on the larger. While the galley on the 3500 resembles more closely a sandwich board, on the 37 and up, they're darn nice, although having wood cabinets directly above a pot of boiling water doesn't make good sense. Yet in all models, the amount of storage space is more than adequate, plus sensibly designed with spaces to store pots as well as dishes without any contortionist exercises.

Tiara

The trained eye can't fail but to notice the detail work on this hatch cover. Have you had enough of glued-on insulation falling off? That's not going to happen with this one.

TiaraEdit-3a.JPG

Even though a bit too much is crammed into this 3500 engine compartment, it's hard not to be impressed by the high quality detail work, starting with fluorescent lighting and the deep hatch gutters to keep water out.

As a true sport fisherman, both the 35 and 43 flunk the test by virtue of cockpits compromised for the cocktail crowd. There is altogether too much upholstery and obstructions for those who are going to give a cockpit a lot of hard use. Some of this glitz is optional, so you'll need to check on how much can be eliminated from the show models. On the 35, the large, L-shaped settee at forward cockpit creates a serious traffic bottle neck, leaving only a 14" wide walk thru. Along with a hinged, pneumatically operated rear seat, there are too many obstructions. For sports-minded people, for the outdoorsy types, the last thing you want is clutter in the cockpit; that's for the cocktail cruisers where seating a lot of people is the primary requirement.

On attention to design detail, we're getting close to as good as it gets. I'm talking about things like:

  • Whether salt water is going to leak all over your engines and machinery when you go to sea. Or when you hit the deck with a hose to wash it. Take a look at the hatch design detail in the nearby photo. A hatch like that probably costs 4X what the run of the mill hatch would cost. Notice that the insulation is not just glued on so that it's going to fall off in a few years. And that you can take the underliner off in order to replace the insulation when it gets all tore up, as it inevitably will.
  • Hatch gutters: The gutters on the electrically lifted large hatch section are very large and deep. The drains are 2" diameter so they won't clog up easily. Know what happens when an improperly designed drainage system gets clogged up? Yep, the water overflows and onto tens of thousands of dollars worth of machinery. If you wonder why we ridicule bad design, that's it.
  • Details like the hatch and cabinet doors are thru-bolted, not screwed into fiberglass.
  • Details like the transom door hinges are double thick stainless with an adequately constructed jamb so the whole arrangement isn't going to break apart from the tremendous leverage applied by the door.
  • Details like proper rounding of fiberglass moldings so they don't fracture at sharp angles.
  • Details like gaskets and strong dogs on all hatches.
  • Overall better quality hardware.
  • A properly constructed hull/deck joint and rub rails so that 5 years from the time you write the check, the side of your boat doesn't look like it went through a hurricane
  • Strong windshields with base gutters to drain off the inevitable leakage.
  • Well laid out electric panels. Various other switches and panels aren't scattered all over the place. For example, on one new boat we recently looked at, we found electrical controls in five different locations, taking a good hour just to figure out where things were and how they operated. On these boats, everything is instantly clear; never spent more than a minute looking for a switch.

The day prior to writing this, I did a survey on a 36 footer that had the electric panel crunched between the helm and the cabin side, literally at floor level. Had to get on my hands and knees to operate a switch. How on earth could anyone tolerate such a thing, I wondered. I mean, is it someone's idea of great fun to have to stand on your head to read a volt meter or throw a switch?  Talk about a designer with his head up his ass. Where are the panels on a Tiara? At eye level where they should be.

I could go on and on, but you get the picture. Real quality is not only in materials but in the design details, all of which make ownership and operation of the vessel far 6easier and less costly, often requiring you pay for things once, rather than twice or three times.

The engine compartments on all the Tiaras were something of a let down. Not that they're not loaded with good quality stuff, but like a Sea Ray, not much thought was given to how anyone is going to reach a lot of stuff for repair or service. If you're a do-it-yourselfer, this has got to give you a pause for consideration. Even with the opening full deck section, things are still hard to reach, yet it's hard not to be impressed with the quality.

Tiara Engine Compartment

The down side on the smaller models. Some engine compartments that can be pretty cramped. It's extremely hard to reach anything. That's the transmission down there.

As you can see in the photo above, there's a nice, easy-clean glass headliner, along with fluorescent lighting so at least you can see what you're doing. The problem is simply too much in too small a space. You got your nice big cabin and cockpit, but this is the price you pay for that.

But you'll find other great features like the cabin door on really good rollers and also with a sliding screen. Both slide as easy as can be. And the electrically opened center windshield is another nice feature. So too is the manner in which the Bimini top is fitted to the windshield; it has only an 8" high eisenglass zippered section that is easy to open to let the air through. Neat.

I also like the heavily rounded toe rails with at least a 4" radius. Not only does this look good, but it makes the gunwale stronger and much less prone to stress cracking when you really bang against a piling.

Another real strong point is the ergonomics of the helm which I found superb, particularly with an electrically operated helm seat. Of course, this is just another electric gizmo to crap out on you, but like electric seats in a car, it is a nice feature. However, if you like to sit and steer with your hands, forget it. This is one for sitting back and steering with your feet, which is my usual method.

One thing Tiara did that is a real head scratcher is that they made the deck up under the windshield black. I don't think I need explain why that is not good for a variety of reasons.

Tiara 3500 Helm

The helm designs are generally superb. This is the 3500 with a power seat.

Easy boarding. Some of the cockpit designs we've seen lately are truly atrocious. It's hard to image that a designer figures that you could tolerate only boarding over the transom, or having to climb all over the upholstered seating -- or worse yet -- walking across a wet bar. But they do. The 3500 has a built-in step each side, which is completely out of the way so you don't get to trip over it, and immediately behind the arch where there is a handy grab rail. And with that pointed diamond non-skid pattern, there's no chance of slipping and getting your bones rearranged. Even Grandma could board with relative ease. But, if you like to mimic the Europeans, who apparently don't have many docks, she's got a 30" wide platform that is removable. It looks like it's integral, but it's not.

Aside from the upholstery, there isn't much in the cockpit area to go to rot and ruin. The little wet bar has a heavily rounded, deep lid with no steel hardware and not much else. Apparently Tiara designers know that salt water comes cascading over the bow to frequently douse the cockpit with that wonderfully corrosive fluid. If stuff can't withstand salt water, it shouldn't be on a boat. In this case, it isn't. Plus you may think that the windshield is ungainly high -- would you like to have a nice, sleek, low Euro style windshield. Well, just keep in mind that the high windshield keeps salt spray off most of your goodies at the helm. Euro style is great in the showroom but it sucks canal water in out here in the real world.

Clearly Tiara is taking a run at being the quality leader. Equally clear is that they're getting close, particularly with the smaller models. In the forty foot range, the engine rooms are a bit of a disappointment and don't measure up to Hatteras or Viking, the later of which has the best machinery installations of any production builder.

If you're not an aficionado, this won't much matter to you. But for today's yachtsmen, a well designed and gleaming machinery space ranks just as high as the exterior appearance, a throwback to our early days of hot-rodding and chrome plating everything. Half the fun of ownership is show-and-tell, like cruising the burger stand on Friday night and opening your hood for all to see. Hey, buddy, whatcha got in there? My Awlgripped, chrome plated 8V92, turbocharged, after burner Dee Twa Diesels, man. The ones with the 250 cc injectors, man. Good for one weeks fishin' and then rebuild 'em. Divorced the wife, bought a boat. A hot rod boat, that is. And why the heck not? Nobody makes a car these days anyone could have an ounce of pride in owning. They're all the same plastic junk. Not even a spot of chrome left on a Jaguar, for God's sake.

It's an injection molded, throw-away, plastic world out there folks. Boats like these represent the last of the world of quality and pride in ownership in something that is mass produced. For those who can afford it.

For the time being, for production builders who turn out a lot of boats, I'll give Tiara the number two spot behind Viking.

See ya at Walker's, chum. Wanna race?

Posted May 20, 1999

Boat Reviews Articles At-A-Glance

  • Introduction to Boat Reviews
  • Albemarle 305
  • Aquasport 215
  • Baha 260 Targa (not "Baja")
  • Bertram Yachts
  • Bertram Yachts: Introduction
  • Bertram 26.6 II
  • Bertram 28 II
  • Bertram 30 Express
  • Bertram 30 Moppie
  • Bertram 31 SF
  • Bertram 33 SF
  • Bertram 36 Moppie
  • Bertram 42 Convertible
  • Bertram 46 Convertible
  • Blackfin Yachts
  • Blackfin 29 SF
  • Blackfin 29 Combi
  • Blackfin 32 Flybridge
  • Blackfin 33
  • Boston Whaler Outrage 26
  • Cabo 31 Sport Express
  • Century 3000
  • Chris-Craft 302 Crown
  • Contender 25
  • Cranchi Mediterranee 40
  • Cruisers 4270 Esprit
  • Cruisers 4280
  • Glacier Bay 2640 Renegade
  • Grady-White Offshore 24
  • Grady-White 24 Voyager
  • Gulfstar 43  Trawler-style Yacht
  • Hatteras Yachts
  • Hatteras Yachts: Introduction
  • Hatteras 36 Convertible
  • Hatteras 38 Convertible
  • Hatteras 38 Convertible - Updated Review
  • Hatteras 39 Sport Express
  • Hatteras 45 Convertible
  • Hatteras 52 Convertible
  • Hatteras 53 Motor Yacht & Convertible
  • Hatteras 61 Motor Yacht
  • Hyatt 45 CMY
  • Island Gypsy 40
  • Legacy 34 Express
  • Luhrs 320 Open
  • Luhrs 34 - 340 F.B. Sedan
  • Luhrs Tournament 360
  • Mainship 31
  • Mainship 350 Trawler
  • Mako 221- Updated 11/05/99
  • Maxum 4600 1998
  • Morgan 462 Ketch
  • Offshore 48
  • Post 46 Convertible
  • Pursuit 2855
  • Pursuit 3000 Offshore
  • Sea Ray and Balsa Core Bottoms (from "Structural Issues")
  • Sea Ray Sundancer 290
  • Sea Say Sundancer 290 Update
  • Sea Ray 370 AC
  • Sea Ray 39 Express
  • Sea Ray 500
  • Shamrock 26
  • Thompson Santa Cruz 2700
  • Tiara 3100 Open
  • Tiara 3600 Convertible
  • Topaz 28_1981
  • Trojan 10-8 Meter
  • Trojan 14 Meter Convertible
  • Trojan 440 Express
  • Viking 43 Open
  • from other cat.
  • Marlin Monroe 42 Bertram Convertible Make an Old Boat New
  • Tiara Today The New Quality Leader?

Mid Size Power Boats

David Pascoe's Power Boat Books

Mid Size Power Boats

  • Basic Considerations
  • Boat Types: Which is Right for You?
  • Old Boats, New Boats and Quality
  • Basic Hull Construction
  • Evaluating Boat Hulls
  • Performance and Sea Keeping
  • Decks & Superstructure
  • Stress Cracks,Finishes and Surface Defects
  • Power Options
  • The Engine Room
  • Electrical & Plumbing Systems
  • Design Details
  • Steering, Controls, Systems & Equipment
  • The Art of the Deal
  • Boat Shopping
  • The Survey & Post Survey
  • Boat Builders by Company
  • What is Pre-Purchase Survey?
  • Business Practices and Client Relations
  • Sound vs. Seaworthiness
  • Hull and Its Structure
  • Surveying the Hull
  • Using Moisture Meters
  • Stress Cracks & Surface Irregularities
  • Deck & Superstructure
  • Drive Train
  • Gas Engines
  • Fuel Systems
  • Exhaust Systems
  • Electrical Systems
  • Plumbing Systems
  • The Marine Investigator
  • The Nature of Investigations
  • The Nature of Evidence
  • Marine Insurance and Issues of Law
  • Bilge Pumps & Batteries
  • Finding the Leak
  • Sinking Due To Rain
  • Fire Investigations
  • Machinery Failure Analysis
  • Fraud Investigations
  • Interrogation Techniques
  • Deposition & Court Testimony

YACHTSURVEY.com

Published by: D. H. Pascoe & Co., Inc. Articles, Images: Copyright © 1997 - 2018 David H. Pascoe All rights reserved. Articles, Images: Copyright © 2019-2020 Junko A. Pascoe All rights reserved. Web site design & developement: Copyright © 1997 - 2021 Junko A. Pascoe All rights reserved. Web site: Maintained by Junko A. Pascoe

Visit our Popular Forums

  • Monohull Sailboats
  • Multihull Sailboats
  • Powered Boats
  • General Sailing
  • Antares Yachts
  • Fountaine Pajot
  • Lagoon Catamarans

Cruising Business

  • Boat Classifieds
  • General Classifieds
  • Crew Positions
  • Commercial Posts
  • Vendor Spotlight

Life Aboard a Boat

  • Provisioning: Food & Drink
  • Families, Kids, & Pets Afloat
  • Recreation, Entertainment, & Fun
  • Boat Ownership & Making a Living
  • Liveaboard's Forum

Seamanship, Navigation & Boat Handling

  • Seamanship & Boat Handling
  • Training, Licensing, & Certification
  • Health, Safety, & Related Gear
  • Rules of the Road, Regulations, & Red Tape

Engineering & Systems

  • Const. / Maint. / Refit
  • Product / Service Reviews
  • Electronics: Comms / AV
  • Electrical: Batts / Gen / Solar
  • Lithium Power Systems
  • Engines & Propulsion
  • Propellers & Drive Systems
  • Plumbing / Fixtures
  • Deck Hdw: Rigging / Sails
  • Aux. Equipment & Dinghy
  • Anchoring & Mooring

Photo Categories

  • Member Galleries
  • Life Onboard
  • Sailing in the Wind
  • Power Boats
  • Cruising Destinations
  • Maint. & Boat Building
  • Marine Life
  • Scuba Diving & Divers
  • General Photos

Recent Photos

tiara yachts vs sea ray

Listing Categories

  • African Cats
  • view more »
  • Crew Wanted
  • Crew Available
  • Enhance Your Account
  • Meet the Mods
  • Meet the Advisors
  • Signup for The Daily Cruiser Email
  > >

Cruiser Wiki

 
Please support our sponsors and let them know you heard about their products on Cruisers Forums.
25-02-2014, 06:41  
experience in mid sized I/O bowriders, most of my life.

I am looking at a cruiser between 35 and 40 foot range and and four winns look pretty good to me.

But with little experience with a like this i would love to get some feedback on which brand is better and what a newbee should be looking for.

It would be used in (florida) and hopefully move around a fair bit (2 adults 2 max) with stay-overs no longer than a week.

Any feedback would be wonderful and appreciated, even if another brand/type would be better.

Thanks....
25-02-2014, 07:11  
25-02-2014, 07:23  
Boat: 48 Wauquiez Pilot Saloon
to 65' Hattari ... (Hatteras) and
NEITHER of these would be my 1st... 5th... or 10th... choice....

Don't get me wrong... They just fine as ... but there are SOOOOO Many other brands out there I think are superior...

Hatteras, Chris Craft, Bertram, Egg Harbor, Tiara, Carver, Grady White, Robalo, Wellcraft, Ocean, Mainship.... This is a 30 second list... TONS of others... Out of the two, the Ray isn't the worst...

is the only choice....
25-02-2014, 07:41  
just fine as boats... but there are SOOOOO Many other brands out there I think are superior...

Hatteras, Chris Craft, Bertram, Egg Harbor, Tiara, Carver, Grady White, Robalo, Wellcraft, Ocean, Mainship.... This is a 30 second list... TONS of others... Out of the two, the Ray isn't the worst...

is the only choice....
25-02-2014, 07:51  
is no object, I'd go Chris Craft or Cobalt.

and Four Winns are good bets at a mid-level point.
25-02-2014, 07:54  
Boat: Key West 2020 CC
line. You should have a that is competent in this area. They are not the only company that used balsa coring below the line, but the quality of their workmanship and materials needs a thorough .
A lot of for the if you find a good one.
Tiara, as mentioned above deserves a look also.
25-02-2014, 08:00  
Boat: 48 Wauquiez Pilot Saloon
25-02-2014, 08:07  
that is competent in this area. They are not the only company that used balsa coring below the water line, but the quality of their workmanship and materials needs a thorough .
A lot of boat for the money if you find a good one.
Tiara, as mentioned above deserves a look also.
25-02-2014, 08:11  
these new... If you are, then yes... my mentioned brands are pretty spendy... Nothing wrong with the Ray

or Ahem... The Winns... Just not what I would do at all.... Maybe I'm biased, but experience with a 35' Four Loser 20 years ago... biggest piece of dog I ever set my butt behind the ... Crap performance/stability/manuverability/... and.... Fit/finish.... Who knows??? Maybe they are great boats now???

Ray is OK, again... my experience was with an older mid 90's boat... 37' Normal IO problems and .... Most bad stuff goes away with an inboard diesel here....

Make up a fictional dollar amount.... I'll go to YW for you and pick my top 5...
25-02-2014, 08:19  
Boat: 48 Wauquiez Pilot Saloon
....... thanks

If i go used i will prolly try to find a (i guess?)
25-02-2014, 08:24  
Boat: Key West 2020 CC
25-02-2014, 08:28  
25-02-2014, 08:37  
25-02-2014, 08:38  
Boat: 48 Wauquiez Pilot Saloon












BRAND NEW...


25-02-2014, 08:41  
Boat: 48 Wauquiez Pilot Saloon
 
Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
:
Posting Rules
post new threads post replies post attachments edit your posts is are code is are are are
No Threads to Display.
- - - - - - -

Privacy Guaranteed - your email is never shared with anyone, opt out any time.

  • 2024 BOAT BUYERS GUIDE
  • Email Newsletters
  • Boat of the Year
  • 2024 Freshwater Boat and Gear Buyers Guide
  • 2024 Boat Buyers Guide
  • 2024 Water Sports Boat Buyers Guide
  • 2024 Pontoon Boat Buyers Guide
  • Cruising Boats
  • Pontoon Boats
  • Fishing Boats
  • Personal Watercraft
  • Water Sports
  • Boat Walkthroughs
  • What To Look For
  • Watersports Favorites Spring 2022
  • Boating Lab
  • Boating Safety
  • Ultimate Boat Giveaway

Boating Magazine Logo

Tiara 3500 Sovran

  • By Kevin Falvey
  • Updated: December 4, 2007

tiara yachts vs sea ray

Tiara 3500 Sovran Specs

Falvey’s Rule states that if speed in mph is greater than fuel consumption in gph, at any given rpm, the cruiser is efficient at that speed. A comparison of performance charts proves it time and again. If you want a 35′ express that adheres to the rule throughout its entire cruising range, grab the helm of Tiara’s 3500 Sovran. Few boats its size and type can match this efficiency. Fewer still offer comparable finish, rigging, and construction. None offers a standard hardtop with a solid, three-sided glass enclosure or the accommodation space provided by the 3500 Sovran. These features make the 3500 Sovran the benchmark of its class.

Luck, Pluck, or Serendipity? The largest contributor to the 3500 Sovran’s efficiency is Volvo Penta’s IPS tractor drive system, which, coupled to twin 301-bhp D-4 diesels, provides brisk acceleration and tactile handling. Press the controls forward. The boat hustles, planing with no lag and little hill climbing. Given the 3500 Sovran’s modest deadrise and wide beam, I was pleased but hardly awestruck. IPS made this boat shine during maneuvers. Instead of logy turning and slow response to the wheel, the 3500 Sovran cut smooth turns at speed, even its top end of 37.4 mph. And at the dock, where a 3-knot current was running, the much-heralded IPS joystick allowed me to twirl, sidestep, and pause with the precision of Fred and Ginger dancing the tango. I’m a rightie, so I appreciated the joystick’s position on the port side of the helm. (Aboard most boats, it’s to starboard, near the lever controls.) When I turn around to back in the boat, I find it easier to manipulate a joystick with my favored hand.

IPS doesn’t get enough credit for the way in which it enhances accommodations. Aboard no boat is this more evident than on the 3500 Sovran. Tiara is acclaimed for straight inboard boats, eschewing stern drives and V-drives. That meant the engine room bulkhead, due to the length of the drive train, was at the companionway steps, allowing for only one stateroom. Step through the 3500 Sovran’s screened companionway for an object lesson in how a propulsion system can affect interior layout and design.

IPS engines are mounted aft, so the 3500 Sovran’s engine room bulkhead is aft as well, providing for an aft cabin, which Tiara refers to as the theater. This name arises as much from the aft cabin’s layout as from what Tiara believes is the 3500 Sovran’s primary mission: partying a crowd, dining four to six, and sleeping the owners for the weekend. This cabin features two opposing sofas, where four can watch the game on the flat-panel TV ($1,860) hung on the aft bulkhead. Since this area is down a step from the main salon, and the companionway stairs don’t impede the entry’s width, it’s comfortable going between here and the salon, head, or galley during a commercial. It’s natural to look over your shoulder from here and speak to someone seated at the dinette or fixing eats in the galley. At the same time, it provides a semi-private area in which to read or work while your mate watches TV or is otherwise occupied elsewhere in the cabin. The backrest removes easily-putting it back is a chore-becoming the filler that converts the theater sofa to a double berth. More guests? The dinette converts to twins. You can sleep six, although aboard a boat this size, that amounts to turning a waterborne cottage into a dorm.

The main salon is flooded with light. Five oversize portlights, two fixed skylights, a D-shaped deck hatch forward, and the light radiating through the acrylic companionway hatch ensure a bright feel. Most builders are creating ways to allow more sun belowdecks. Tiara goes a step further, flowing all that natural light through the boat. Note the translucent insert in the teak shower partition in the head, the generous height and width of the aft cabin entry, and the curved teak hanging lockers that bracket the entrance to the master berth, making for less shadow than flat-sided cabinets, bulkheads, or ring frames. This suffusion of light contributes to the feeling of space wrought by high sidedecks, a wide beam, and topsides displaying much convexity.

A Class of One? I had a hard time making comparisons with the 3500 Sovran, primarily because of its wide beam. Although there are plenty of other cruisers with nominally similar LOAs, most either displaced less-displacement’s a great way to compare interior volumes-or carried less beam. They’re smaller boats, despite their length-based model designations. So look at Formula’s 37 Performance Cruiser ($518,550, powered like my test boat). It posts identical performance, in addition to having a larger swim platform and twin bow sunpads. It doesn’t offer the hardtop and solid glass enclosure you get with the 3500 Sovran, so you’ll have to deal with canvas.

You’ll also want to demo Sea Ray’s 340 Sundancer ($304,634 with twin 375-hp MerCruiser 496 MAG DTS Seacore Bravo Three gasoline stern drives). Gas stern drives? Versus diesel tractors? When I tested it, the 340 Sundancer adhered to Falvey’s Rule at speeds between 24 and 36 mph. Economy drops off precipitously after that. But since you’re not buying diesel engines, you save cash up front, effectively getting seasons’ worth of higher fuel burn for free. The 340 Sundancer tops out at 46 mph, and it doesn’t offer joystick docking. Nibral (nickel-bronze-aluminum) IPS drives are better suited to saltwater than aluminum stern drives. Interestingly, IPS for gas engines is just coming out. In fact, it’s one the 3500 Sovran’s power options (twin 375-hp, $334,000). A comparison test would be great. (Tiara? Sea Ray? Formula? Any takers?)

Until then, the 3500 Sovran’s huge and delightful cabin, coupe helm enclosure, efficiency, and joystick docking convenience, all for a middle-of-the-road price, make it my top pick.

Extra Point : Accessories such as the generator controls, filters, and pumps are mounted on a false bulkhead in the engine compartment, making service and installation easier.

Tiara Yachts  – Holland, Michigan; 616-392-7163 ;  tiarayachts.com

  • More: boat tests , Cruising Boats , express cruisers , Tiara Yachts

Boat trailer with short bunks

Is Your Trailer Right for Your Boat?

Genesis Marine Technologies 24

Genesis Marine Technologies 24: Our First Impression

Invincible 46 Pilothouse running offshore

Five of the Top Power Catamarans

Shield Trailer with a wake sports boat

The Boat Trailer of Tomorrow

Servicing a sterndrive

Midseason Sterndrive Maintenance

Tools for splicing wires on a boat

How to Properly Splice Wires on Your Boat

Sharing a lake with wakeboaters

Sharing the Lake With Wakeboaters

Slalom skier behind the boat

Take Your Tow-Sports Skills to the Next Level

Boating Magazine Logo

  • Digital Edition
  • Customer Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cruising World
  • Sailing World
  • Salt Water Sportsman
  • Sport Fishing
  • Wakeboarding

Many products featured on this site were editorially chosen. Boating may receive financial compensation for products purchased through this site.

Copyright © 2024 Boating Firecrown . All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.

IMAGES

  1. Tiara Vs Sea Ray

    tiara yachts vs sea ray

  2. Sea Ray 290 Sundancer MERCRUISER Cruiser YACHT Chaparral TIARA FOUR

    tiara yachts vs sea ray

  3. 2022 Tiara Yachts 48 Yacht For Sale

    tiara yachts vs sea ray

  4. 1996 Sea Ray 330 Sea Ray Specs And Pricing

    tiara yachts vs sea ray

  5. Tiara Vs Sea Ray

    tiara yachts vs sea ray

  6. TIARA YACHTS Yacht CRUISER IPS Volvo PENTA Cabo SEA RAY Regal FORMULA

    tiara yachts vs sea ray

COMMENTS

  1. Comparing Cruisers

    Tiara 3900 Sovran Tiara Yachts. Another Option…Tiara 3900 Sovran ... Sea Ray 450 Sundancer Sea Ray Boats. 45 Feet: Sea Ray 450 Sundancer Set up primarily for entertaining, the 450 Sundancer offers a master stateroom forward in an otherwise open plan that features a media room aft, which can sleep two. No doubt, cruisers in this size category ...

  2. 35'-38' Express Cruisers: Six Good Boats to Compare

    Six Good Boats to Compare. Sea Ray 370 Sundancer. Formula 37 Performance Cruiser. Regal 35 Sport Coupe. Cruisers Yachts 38 Express. Bavaria Sport 360 HT. Beneteau Gran Turismo 35. We have six express cruisers in what many experienced skippers think is a good compromise between size and cost. These boats are big enough for four people to ...

  3. 420 SD vs Tiara 4300 Sovran

    The Sea Ray is a solid boat with a bullet proof and low maintenance propulsion package. It wins on the space. ... The Tiara is in salt, and the Sea Ray is all freshwater. Thoughts? Thanks, Scott . Dec 27, 2013 #13 HUMPH Well-Known Member. Nov 4, 2009 7,618 SF BAY AREA Boat Info

  4. We Compare 20'-21' Sportboats: 3 Affordable Bowriders

    The lighter-weight outboard boat is a bit faster at MPH WOT (40.4 knots vs. 39.7); cruises a tad farther on a tank of fuel (157 vs. 145 n.m.); is a whisker faster at the most efficient speed (23.8 vs. 23.4 knots.); and costs $1,108 less, $41,493 base vs. $42,601, per the Sea Ray website.

  5. Boat Test: 2024 Tiara Yachts 48 LE

    Contact Tiara Yachts. Tiara Yachts - Holland, Michigan; 616-392-7163 ; tiarayachts.com. More: 2024, 40-50ft, April 2024, boat tests, Boats, Cruising Boats, outboards, Tiara Yachts. The 48 LE turns heads with its styling, offers a wealth of entertainment options, and is capable of handling even the sportiest boating conditions.

  6. 2021 Tiara Sport 43 LE Boat Test, Pricing, Specs

    Speed, Efficiency, Operation. Tiara Yachts - Holland, Michigan; 616-392-7163 ; tiarayachts.com. In this article, a Boating Certified Boat Test, Boating Editor-in-Chief Kevin Falvey explores the performance, price and offers shopping advice for this new 2021 Tiara Sport 43 LE. A must-read for those in the market for a large, outboard-powered ...

  7. Tiara Yachts EX 60 Reviewed

    The 40-knot Tiara EX 60 is a yacht focused on function, performance and luxury. The easy side-deck access off the helm will come in handy when shorthanded cruising. Courtesy Tiara Yachts. When Tiara Yachts created a new flagship for its fleet, it went big: The Tiara EX 60 is a full 10 feet longer than any other Tiara.

  8. Tiara 3100 Open

    Tiara's 3100 Open is sought after for its high quality and practicality. It's no surprise that the Tiara 3100 keeps popping up on Sea magazine's list of most desirable brokerage boats. The best way to find out about the inner workings of a boat is usually upside down, contorted like a soft pretzel. Upon crawling back out of the hole into which ...

  9. Boat Reviews by David Pascoe, Marine Surveyor

    David Pascoe - Biography. " Marine Investigations " (2004). Over 80 used boat reviews by David Pascoe, marine surveyor "The purpose of these boat reviews is educational, to help you discern the differences in quality among boats generally. They are not offered as a means to help you evaluate any particular boat builder."

  10. Top 10 Cruisers of 2016

    Cruising boats from the likes of Tiara, Jeanneau, Azimut, Beneteau, and Sea Ray make our list. By Gary Reich. December 1, 2016. The thrill of exploration and discovering new places on the water is why we love boating, and cruising boats like the ones we picked in 10 Top Express Cruisers: Favorites for Family Boating Fun will be ideal for a ...

  11. TIARA 3100 Open

    In 2012, David Pascoe has retired from marine surveying business at age 65. On November 23rd, 2018, David Pascoe has passed away at age 71. Biography - Long version. A multipurpose boat with flair: The 3100 has long been one of my favorites in terms of both good styling, layout, quality and reasonable seaworthiness.

  12. Tiara 36 Convertible

    In 2012, David Pascoe has retired from marine surveying business at age 65. On November 23rd, 2018, David Pascoe has passed away at age 71. Biography - Long version. > >. The Tiara 3600 is a high quality boat that stands the test of time. Good looking without a lot of eye candy, it has nice clean lines and the kind of styling that is nearly ...

  13. 2023 Tiara EX 60 Boat Test, Pricing, Specs

    Tiara EX 60 Certified Test Results Boating Magazine. Contact Tiara Yachts. Tiara Yachts - Holland, Michigan; 616-392-7163 ; tiarayachts.com. More: 2023, 60-70ft, boat tests, Boats, Cruising Boats, diesel, ips, May 2023, Tiara Yachts. The EX 60 combines the superb quality in construction and finish that Tiara is known for with a satisfying ...

  14. 21'-22' Sportboats: We Compare Three Entry-Level Bowriders

    The Sea Ray has a single bucket seat; hence more cockpit seating. The Tahoe's sun pad is set up for athwartships lounging, while the Glastron's converts to aft-facing chaises, overlooking the swim platform. If the devil's in the details, for this quartet details make the boat. Sea Ray SPX 210. Sea Ray builds the SPX 210 as an all-purpose ...

  15. Tiara Yachts

    Tiara Yachts is a boat manufacturer headquartered in Holland, Michigan, and is one of the oldest privately held boat manufacturers in the United States. The company, founded in 1974 by Leon Slikkers, manufactures luxury inboard and outboard yachts ranging from 34-60 feet. [1]

  16. Tiara Yachts Boat Reviews

    Tiara 50 Coupe, Molding a Modern Blend. The mold says a lot about the hull it will produce, but it's just the beginning on the way to a boat called the Tiara 50 Coupe. …. Read More. The latest Tiara Yachts boat reviews featuring first look videos, tests, specifications, and information resources.

  17. 2020 Tiara Sport 38 LX Boat Test, Pricing, Specs

    Courtesy Tiara Yachts. If you're shopping, look at the Tiara Sport 38 LS ($642,590); it's the same hull, but with a walk-around deck and full cabin with berth and shower. For a dual-console comparison, sea-trial Grady-White's Freedom 375 ($606,900 with triple Yamaha F350s, Helm Master and Bow Thruster). It's 18 inches shorter, 8 inches ...

  18. 10 Yachts You Can Have Now

    Sea Ray's Fly 520 is the builder's bridge boat into its yacht class. Sea Ray. I've been reviewing Sea Rays since company founder Connie Ray was still driving the train, and I've often used adjectives like well-built and ­family-friendly to describe new models. But when I stepped aboard the Sea Ray Fly 520, a different word came to mind ...

  19. Whats Better? SeaRay or Regal?

    But Sea Ray deckboats and Select bowriders are more plush than Regal. Some insiders say the Regals have better construction. Sea Ray may have an edge in customer service, of course that is mostly up to your local dealer. Regal deckboats and bowriders are typically priced well under Sea Ray. More at the Four Winns price level.

  20. Tiara yachts: Tiara Today

    No, these boats have some bone deep quality in them. First off, we got to compare the 35 Open with the 4100. As is common in the industry, the overall quality tends to go up with the size and price of the boat, and that is clearly the case here. With the 4300 Open, Tiara is clearly taking a shot at Viking and Hatteras, with all the latest ...

  21. Five Big Bowriders Tested

    Here are five great dayboat mega-bowriders that will exceed your boating expectations. Editor's Note: Check out our in-depth test of each model - Formula 380 SSC OB, Tiara Sport 38 LX, Cruisers Yachts 38 GLS, Monterey 385 SE, Sea Ray SLX 400. The 380 SSC is designed for relaxation and entertainment. Courtesy Formula Boats.

  22. sea ray vs four winns?

    I am looking at a cruiser between 35 and 40 foot range and sea ray and four winns look pretty good to me. But with little experience with a boat like this i would love to get some feedback on which brand is better and what a newbee should be looking for. It would be used in salt water (florida) and hopefully move around a fair bit (2 adults 2 ...

  23. Tiara 3500 Sovran

    The Tiara 3500 Sovran is the benchmark of its class. Falvey's Rule states that if speed in mph is greater than fuel consumption in gph, at any given rpm, the cruiser is efficient at that speed. A comparison of performance charts proves it time and again. If you want a 35′ express that adheres to the rule throughout its entire cruising range ...